Electronic collar. What is the Difference between a Bark Collar and a Training Collar?

Electronic collar. What is the Difference between a bark Collar and a Training Collar?

Now is the time to discuss the topic of choosing electronic dog collars.

In this article I will try to outline not only the main pros and cons of electronic collars, but also highlight the main parameters that are important when choosing and buying electronic collar.

And how long have e-collars been around? 

At the end of the 60s of the last century, the Georgian scientist-ethologist Jason Badridze invented a device that affects the animal using electric pulses to study wolves in their natural habitat.

This device was attached to the neck of animals.

This became the prototype of modern electronic collar. Their production was established in the 70s of the last century in the United States and they were intended mainly for hunters, influencing hunting dogs, not allowing distractions by animals that are not tame.

Scientists have long determined that with the help of e-collar pulses it is possible to influence various animals, but electronic collars for dogs have become widespread.

Not everyone accepted the appearance of electronic collars favorably. This “novelty” caused more negative emotions during the first 20 years and even a number of demonstrations by animal advocates concerned about “cruel” measures of influence on dogs with electronic collars.

For many years, there have been discussions about what is a more humane method of influencing a dog with an electronic collar with its “electric shocks” or a long-established collar with spikes.

But, over time, this controversy has subsided as electronic collars have been modernized, wider possibilities of their use have been studied, new functions have been added, restrictions on the strength of the impulse used have been established and the time has come when electronic collars have been recognized and they are successfully used for training, education or remote control dog.

Electronic collar. What is the Difference between a Bark Collar and a Training Collar?

If you come across the names “radio collar”, “shock collar”, “pulse collar”, “electric training collar”, “remote impact collar” or “anti-barking”, know that all these types of collars belong to electronic dog collars.

In order to determine what exactly interests you, you need to know how electronic collars work and what they are.

What’s an electronic collar?

An electronic collar is a device that acts on a dog using electrical impulses of varying strength and duration, and allows you to control the dog’s actions at a distance.

The control of such a device is carried out remotely using the remote control.

The electronic collar allows you to:

  1. Suppress unwanted actions (instincts) of the dog, for example: aggression towards other dogs,
  2. Chasing a cat or other animals, picking up unwanted objects from the ground, barking,
  3. Aggression towards people, etc.;
  4. To form conditioned reflexes to indicate the correct actions of the dog (used in combination with encouragement);
  5. Prepare the dog and train the dog for tracking or different sports;
  6. Put the animal’s attention to the trainer during training;

What electrical impulses are used in work:

  • Sound;
  • Vibration;
  • Electricity

What types of stimulation are used when working with an electric collar:

  1. single – single discharge, exposure time is about 0.2 sec;
  2. growing – a gradual increase in the level of electrical stimulation during the discharge, exposure
  3. time from one to several seconds;
  4. constant – continuous exposure to the dog for several seconds

The fact that the possibilities of using electronic collars are wide enough has long been known and, depending on their purpose, they were divided into groups.

Since when choosing an electric collar, you must first decide on the functions that it should perform, let’s look at what electronic collars are today.


Training collar. This is the most widely represented group of collars with the widest range of functions. This includes collars:

  1. to correct the behavior of dogs
  2. teaching commands or honing existing dog skills
  3. working dog training
  4. training of sports dogs
  5. weaning dogs from certain undesirable habits (picking up objects from the ground, chasing pigeons, cats).

All types of stimulation and their various combinations are used in these collars.

The number of combinations of impulse effects on a dog ranges from several options to hundreds. These collars have different ranges and are the widest range on the market.



These collars allow using a satellite navigation system to track the physical location of the dog, with their help, you can prevent the abduction of dogs, do not allow animals to leave the designated area, and guide the movement of the animal during the hunt.

Most often, this type of collar is used while hunting.

Electronic collar. What is the Difference between a Bark Collar and a Training Collar?

Tracking collars are often designed for multiple dogs at once, allowing multiple animals to be controlled using a single remote control.



These collars are designed to stop the dog’s frequent annoying barking.

Basically, such collars do not give the animal any pain, since impulses of the least force are used to have a negative (not pleasant for the animal) effect on the dog.



Containment systems “electronic fence“. Collars of this group do not allow dogs to leave the designated area of the territory, exerting an impact on the dog when crossing the border.

These containment systems are often used in the protection of territories or the allocation of territory that is not desirable to visit.
 Read here more about 7 Best Dog Electric Fence

Dog Training Basics with an electronic collar

Each dog has a character and an individual approach is required during training. When using an electronic collar, it is also necessary to take into account the individual sensitivity of the animal to electrical impulses.

Sensitivity depends on many factors, including the well-being of the dog, its mood, weather conditions (humidity).

Before you start training, you need to consider whether you can handle the dog on your own or it is better to use the services of a qualified trainer.

E-Collar training requires careful preparation, so let’s take a look at the main points on which your overall training success depends.

Electronic collar. What is the Difference between a Bark Collar and a Training Collar?

1. Confidence in choice. You must be sure that you have purchased a reliable collar and a comfortable collar designed specifically for your chosen purposes (training, behavior correction) and that you have the opportunity to choose different modes to change the strength of the impact on the animal.

2.No collar can harm a dog when used correctly. Before using the collar, you need to determine the strength of the pulses you will be using.

It is most correct to test the collar on your own hand, starting with the smallest impulse (often the human hand does not even recognize it) and increasing to a tingling sensation in the hand, emanating from the collar electrodes.

Remember that the sensitivity of a dog is 8-10 times higher than that of a human, and those impulses that are barely perceptible with your hand will be well felt by your dog.

3.Lack of discomfort. Your dog should not be uncomfortable with the e-collar.

To do this, she must get used to the feel of the collar around her neck some time before training with electrical impulses.

Attach the e-collar next to the collar and allow the dog to move around in it. Your dog shouldn’t be alarmed when you put an electronic collar on it.

4.Concentration of attention. It is difficult to train the dog or make adjustments to its behavior in an environment that is not conducive to the concentration of the animal’s attention.

For example, children playing around or walking animals, passing cars, or having loud distractions. Only after the team has been studied, add distractions, shortening the distance and increasing their impact.

5.Promotion. Any command done correctly during training should be encouraged.

It can be a treat, stroking, or a few minutes in an embrace with its favorite toy, whatever, if only the dog feels that you are happy with it and it is doing everything right.

6.Training time. Not all dogs are able to endure long, exhausting, monotonous training.

Break the workout down to maximize your dog’s focus on the task at hand. Then give the animal a little rest and feel free to move on to the next stage of training.


Leave a Comment