20 Best Plush Dog Toys in 2020

Why are dog toys important? They are a sure way of keeping your pets busy to eliminate boredom and also provide a means of conducting physical exercises which would have overall benefits for their health.

Further, dog toys are also essential for distracting the pooches from your shoes and furniture, and as a result, they save you from having to incur nagging replacement costs.

There are various dog toys available, and some are meant for chewing and shaking while others are designed for cuddling and carrying.

If your dog prefers the latter, then a plush toy would be an appropriate choice for them. This is because they are soft and your pooch would enjoy the warmth that it provides.

However, getting the best plush dog toys may not be a straightforward process as you would like. It is very easy for you to go for a fragile toy that your canine would destroy in a matter of minutes.

Luckily for you, we are here to guide you so that you get a plush toy that is worth every cent that you spend on it.

First, there are a number of factors which you need to consider to narrow down your search. They include:

  • The Price
  • Lifespan
  • Size
  • The design and so on

Best Plush Dog Toys 2020: Comparison List

We have gone a step further and reviewed 20 brands which we believe are the best that you can find. This should save you a lot of time in your search.

Let’s check them out.

20 Best Plush Dog Toys for Your Pup

1. Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Plush Puzzle Toy

This is one of the highest-rated plush toys that you may ever find, and you once you go through our review, you ought to have understood why.

To begin with, this toy comes in the form of a plush log containing numerous holes. These holes include several squirrels, with the exact number varying with the size of the toy.

Each squirrel has a squeaker inside which aims to arouse the pet’s curiosity and encourage him to play more.

It is available in three different sizes, small, large and x-large, so you should find the one that suits your pet best.

You should appreciate the versatility of this toy as your pet could play with it alone or with you when you are around.

What's more, is that your pet could play with the log or squirrels separately and this adds to the fun aspect.

Pros

  • Plush and durable
  • Available in different themes (bees, rainbow, birds, and hedgehogs)
  • Can be used for solo or interactive play

Cons

  • Not for the aggressive chewers

2. Smart Pet Love Puppy Snuggle Toy

You must understand the anxious feeling of moving to a new environment where everything seems new and strange. Well, that is precisely how a puppy feels when it is separated from the rest of the pack and taken to a new household.

The SmartPetLove snuggle toy for puppies would play a crucial role in eliminating this anxiety. First, it is fitted with a small vibrator that simulates a real heartbeat.

We should also mention that the heartbeat is powered by AAA batteries.

Also, there is a heat pack that would keep your pup warm for up to 15-hours. As a result, your pet would feel like it has cuddled next to the mother.

A significant advantage is that the toy is machine-washable and can withstand a gentle cycle.

Pros

  • Easy to clean
  • Has a vibrator that simulates a natural heartbeat
  • Ideal size for a puppy to cuddle up in

Cons

  • Only for snuggling and not for playing

3. Multipet HDP Deedle Dudes Mouse That Sings

A tiny squeak tends to arouse your dog’s curiosity and bring out its playful nature, so imagine what a singing toy would do.

Well, that is precisely what you would get with the Multipet Deedle Dudes mouse. This toy is fitted with a voice box that blasts out the Deedle Dudes anthem whenever the toy is squeezed.

It measures 8-inches long, and this is a convenient size to ensure that it is not a choking hazard.

The toy is plush filled to make it ideal for chewing without hurting your pet’s teeth and gums.

Another benefit of having this toy is that it can be used for a game of fetch as well as for solo play.

Lastly, it comes in a pack of one or a pack of two toys.

Pros

  • Has a voice box which makes the toy more appealing to the dog
  • Plush filled and soft
  • Attractive design

Cons

  • Some owners find the singing to be annoying

4. Pawaboo Squeaky Hedgehog Plush Dog Toys

Instead of a squeaker, this toy has a rattle inside which would have the same effect of bringing out your dog’s playful instincts.

Only that this time, you will be spared of the constant squeaking sounds, that some pet owners find to be bothersome.

This toy comes in the form of a hedgehog which should entice your dog to do more chewing and provides a welcome distraction from your furniture or shoes.

It is crafted out of soft faux fur plus has minimal seams to add to its durability. Further, it has three inner layers of sturdy mesh to make it last longer.

There are also the PP cotton fillings that make the toy to be gentle on your pet’s teeth and gums.

To keep it clean, you have various options on the table. You could throw it in the washing machine, hand-wash it or simply wipe off the dust by use of a wet piece of cloth.

Besides the hedgehog, you could also find the plush toys from the brand in the form of a lion or a dinosaur baby as well.

Pros

  • Well-made
  • Can work as an interactive or solo-play toy
  • You can clean it in more than one way

Cons

  • The plastic eyes come off easily and could choke the dog

5. Multipet Duckworth Duck

A game of fetch is one sure way of getting your pooch to exercise, and one appropriate toy that you may use for this purpose is the Duckworth duck toy by multipet.

First, it has a rounded bottom and a narrow neck, to offer sufficient area for your pet to grip.

 It may have a soft texture which makes it gentle for your pooch’s teeth and gums, but it is also well-made to withstand the constant biting.

Further, the toy is available in mini and large sizes, and this makes it suited to a broader range of dogs.

Additionally, it has a squeaker which makes the toy even more fun to play with.

Lastly, you may get it as a single toy or in a pack of two.

Pros

  • Machine-washable
  • Beautiful design
  • Well-priced

Cons

  • The fur comes off too easily and may harm the digestive tract when ingested

6. Peteast 6-toy Pack

This is a toy set that comprises of 3-squeaky toys and 3-rope toys for your dog. The three squeaky toys come in the form of a raccoon, fox and squirrel.

Each of the animals features two squeakers for more sound, entertainment and fun.

You should also appreciate the fact that the three squeaky toys are no-stuffing, and this eliminates the chances of them leaving a huge mess behind in your house.

When it comes to the rope toys, they multi-colored and are made out of natural cotton to make them non-toxic and safe.

Lastly, the toys are dishwasher-safe, implying that they are easy to clean.

Pros

  • Come with a 6-month warranty
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • No-stuffing animals make them mess-free

Cons

  • Short lifespan

7. Ethical Pet Spot Skineeez Stuffingless Dog Toy

If you want your house to be mess-free after your pet is done playing with its toy, then you should go for a stuffing less toy. An excellent example of such a toy is the Skineeez stuffing less toy by Ethical Pet.

The toy has a squeaker inside to encourage the pet to play with the toy more.

What’s more is that the toy is available in many designs including a rabbit, chipmunk, wooly sheep, skunk, squirrel, fox, and raccoon.

It is also available in different sizes, and so all dog sizes are catered for.

To ensure that the toy serves you for the longest time possible, it features a ripstop mesh that is crucial in keeping it in one piece.

To wrap things up, it is machine-washable and therefore, easy to clean.

Pros

  • Comes in different designs to suit all preferences
  • Easy to clean and dry
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Leaves a lot of fur in the dog’s mouth

8. Zippy Paws Woodland Friends Plush Dog Toy

This is another hide-and-seek toy that aims to stimulate your pet's mind and enhance his intelligence. It features three plush hedgehogs fitted inside a log, and your dog would have to pluck them out for fun.

All the animals have squeakers inside and give out a pleasant sound when the pooch squeezes it.

It is available in four different sizes and is ideal for small to medium sized dogs. Additionally, the plush toy is available in four different colors so you can choose the one that suits your style best.

To wrap things up, you can get easily get replacement hedgehogs in case the original ones wear out.

Pros

  • Plush and squeaky
  • Beautiful design
  • Well-made

Cons

  • Squeaker has a short life span

9. Zippy Paws Burrow Hide-and-Seek Plush Toy

ZippyPaws does it again with the burrow hide-and-seek toy that aims to stimulate your pet’s interactive play. It is available in three different styles, namely Meerkat den, Panda n’ Bamboo, and Monkey n’ Banana.

Each animal features a squeaker that would entertain your pet with the sound that it produces when squeezed.

Your dog should have endless hours of fun as it digs the animals out of their holes. This would also play a part in boosting their intelligence.

The toy is ideal for small and medium-sized dogs.

Pros

  • Beautiful design
  • Distracts your dog from the furniture
  • Well-made

Cons

  • Not for the aggressive chewers

10. Chuckit! Indoor Ball Dog Toy

If you feel that your pet would be safer playing indoors, then the Chuckit! Ball dog toy would be an appropriate toy.

Not only would your pooch be safe, but your household surface should remain in one piece too due to the lightweight design of the ball.

Although lightweight, the toy has a multi-layered construction that makes it durable and capable of withstanding the most aggressive and toughest chewers.

The ball has a textured chenille fabric that is gentle on the pet's teeth and gums, plus it makes the toy easy to pick up.

On top of that, the ball rolls quite easily, and this makes it ideal for a game of fetch.

Lastly, it is available in bright colors that make it highly visible and to arouse the pet’s interest in the toy.

Pros

  • Lightweight and durable
  • Textured fabric makes it safe for the mouth
  • Available in bright colors

Cons

  • Too big

11. goDog Plush Toy

Durability has always been an issue with plush toys, but the goDog toy aims to solve this problem. First, it has a spherical shape, and therefore, your pooch would have a particular weak spot that it would focus on.

Then, the Chew Guard technology together with the reinforced seams and the chew-resistant layers, combine to make this toy extremely tough and able to withstand the roughest pets.

Let’s also mention the plush exterior that makes the toy friendly and gentle on the pooch’s teeth and gums.

The squeaker inside gives out a sound when squeezed and thereby keeps the canine entertained for long periods.

Finally, it is available in mini, small, large, and X-large sizes to make the toy ideal for all dog breeds. It is also available in different colors, including purple, rainbow, red, white, lime and teal.

Pros

  • Sturdy and durable
  • Has a soft and plush exterior
  • Decent pricing

Cons

  • The fiber material is a choking hazard

12. Outward Hound Squeaky Matz Dog Toy

The outstanding feature with this toy is that it is fitted with multiple squeakers rather than only one squeaker, and this means it offers more fun and entertainment to the dog.

Although the toy is soft and plush, making it gentle to the pooch’s mouth, it is also quite sturdy and can withstand constant chewing by the dog.

It is designed to have a flat body so that the pet would find it easy to shake and flap the toy around.

The toy comes in various sizes so that it can cater to all dog breeds. Additionally, you have the option of choosing from the gator, duck, and cow design.

Lastly, the toy is ideal for solo play as well as for a game of tug and fetch as well.

Pros

  • Features multiple squeakers
  • Designed for various types of play
  • Sturdy yet gentle on the dog’s mouth

Cons

  • In case it bursts open, you will have to deal with a huge mess

13. Zippy Paws No-Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

The main advantage of a stuffing less dog toy is that there would be no mess for you to clean once your pet is done playing with the toy.

This toy set by Zippy Paws possesses that advantage, and it features three creatures including a raccoon, a squirrel and a fox. 

Each of the toys has three squeakers, and this translates to more entertainment for the pet.

It is available in small and large sizes, and so would suit both classes of dog breeds.

Besides having no stuffing, the toys are crafted from high-quality materials, and this goes a long way in ensuring that they serve you for a long time to come.

Pros

  • Beautiful design
  • Fitted with three squeakers
  • Plush, soft and gentle on the mouth

Cons

  • Falls apart easily

14. Multipet Petco Loofa Dog Toy

The Loofa dog toy offers a comical angle to the dog toys as it features an awkwardly wide grin which makes it seem like the toy is having fun as well.

It is available in mini, small, medium, large and jumbo sizes, meaning that you can find the perfect size for any dog breed.

The toy has a slender design which makes it ideal for a game of fetch since the dog should find it easy to pick up and carry it around.

Your dog should also enjoy snuggling into the toy since it is plush and it would enjoy the comfort that it provides.

Each toy features two squeakers, one in the nose and the other closer to the tail, and this makes it more fun to play with it.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Squeaky
  • It has the jumbo size which suits the largest dog breeds

Cons

  • Not very sturdy

15. Dog Diggin Designs Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

If you are looking to for a classy and fashionable toy for your dog, then the squeaky plush toy by the Dog Diggin Designs is what you are looking for.

It comes in the form of a bone, and this should make it more appealing to your pet. The toy is made out of ultra-soft material which would make the toy to be more comfortable for the canine to hold.

What's more, is that each toy has a squeaker to keep your dog entertained all through.

The toy is available in different colors, patterns, themes, and symbols.

The beautiful and unique design means that this toy could also serve as an appropriate gift for your pooch.

Pros

  • Classy design
  • Soft and squeaky
  • Has an ideal length for your dog to carry the toy in his mouth comfortably

Cons

  • Expensive

16. Multipet 12” Plush Tick Toy

You do not always have to dig deep into your pockets to get the best plush toy for your canine friend. Several budget-friendly options would still give a performance that rivals that of the pricier models.

A good example is this hilarious plush toy by Multipet products which comes in the form of a large tick.

It measures 12-inches long, and this makes the toy to be impressively large.

The outer layer is soft and tactile such that your pet should enjoy holding the toy in its mouth. Then, it has a squeaker somewhere in the belly, and this should keep your pet entertained as it plays with the toy.

The “Pinch me" and "Tick" writings on either side of the toy only add to its charming aspect.

Pros

  • Well-priced
  • Has a squeaker inside
  • Large and soft

Cons

  • Poorly constructed

17. Walter the Wabbit Dog Toy by Fluff & Tuff

If your pooch has a habit of ripping its new plush toys within hours, then the Fluff & Tuff Walter the Rabbit dog toy would be a reasonable solution to this problem.

It features double-stitched seams which are concealed plus it also features the Tuffweb mesh liner. This combination of features gives you a sturdy toy which is capable of withstanding even the most aggressive chewers.

The outer fabric is ultra-plush, and this makes the toy gentle to the dog's mouth. Further, it has non-toxic polyfill stuffings to make it safe for your pet to play with.

You should also appreciate the embroidered eyes that aim to keep your pooch from getting to the stuffings.

The squeaker inside only serves to add to the fun and entertaining nature of this plush toy.

Pros

  • Sturdy construction
  • Has non-toxic stuffings
  • Would not hurt the teeth and gums of the pet during play

Cons

  • A bit pricey

18. Outward Hound Kyjen Magic Hat with Rabbits

This is a unique approach to dog toys as it features a hat with rabbits fitted inside. You would only normally associate such a set with magicians performing for kids, would you?

The hat features three rabbits, each with a squeaker inside to keep your pet entertained for hours.

Then, all the rabbits plus the hat are designed to be durable so that it would be a while before you think about getting your pooch a new toy.

As a puzzle toy, this magic hat set aims to boost your pet's intelligence, and you should note a remarkable improvement in his cognitive skills at the end of the day.

Pros

  • Features three squeaky rabbits
  • Well-made
  • Eliminates boredom

Cons

  • The plastic whiskers on the rabbits could hurt your pooch

19. Fetch Pet Products Hatchables Interactive Plush Dog Toy

When you acquire this toy, you would be getting a 2-in-1 toy set. This is because when you turn the toy inside out, it becomes an ‘egg’ and your pooch would have to figure out how it would transform it back into an animal.

You may get it in a pack of three or in a package of five toys, plus it is also available in various forms including a duck, a toucan, a turtle, chameleon, bluebird or bat.

The toy is tested using the ASTMF963 standards to assure you that you would be dealing with a safe and high-quality product that would not pose any harm to your pet.

All the toys have squeakers to make them more fun to play with. Additionally, they have minimal stuffing to enable a mess-free playtime.

To wrap it all up, you could stuff in treats in the toys to add to the fun aspect of the toy.

Pros

  • Has met the ASTMF963 safety standards
  • Minimal stuffing
  • Squeaky

Cons

  • Only for the light chewers

20. Zanies Plush Stuffing-less Dog Toy

The last item on our list is the no-stuffing dog toy by Zanies that is ideal for solo as well as interactive play such as a game of tug and fetch.

It is available in gopher, squirrel, coyote and chipmunk design, so you can easily pick out the one you feel your pet would enjoy most.

Each toy has two squeakers inside for more sound and fun when squeezed.

The no-stuffing design means that there would be no mess to clean after once the pooch is done playing with the toy.

Lastly, the toy should not crowd your living room since it has a hanging loop that you could use for storage when it is not in use.

Pros

  • Has two squeakers inside
  • No-stuffing to leave your house mess-free
  • The hanging loop makes it easy to store

Cons

  • Not durable

The Buying Guide

As we stated earlier, an ideal dog plush toy should have several essential features. We are going to analyze these factors briefly.

Durability

It is wise that you look out for features that would ensure the toy serves your pet for a decent duration. These features include double-layer constructions, ripstop materials, hidden seams and double stitching.

If the plush toy has any or all of these features, then it should be capable of standing up to even the most aggressive chewers.

The stuffing

If the toy has fillings, then you should ensure that they are non-toxic so that your pet would be safe as it plays about with the toy since there is always the chance that the dog would get to the interior.

Ideally, you may also go for stuffing-less toys which tend to be more durable plus do not leave you with a messy house once the pet is done playing with it.

Size

The size of the toy should vary directly with the pooch's size. If it is too small, it may turn out to be a choking hazard while if it is too large, then the pet would have a hard time carrying it around.

So, ensure that you pick a size with which your dog would be most comfortable.

Mental Stimulation 

You should go for a toy that would pick your pet's mind to boost its intelligence. A good example would be an interactive toy, especially the hide-and-seek and burrow toys where the pooch has to pick out a toy from a hidden part.

The Price 

Your ideal toy should lie within a specific price range so that you can plan for it accordingly. It is vital that you stick to your budget so that you could avoid getting yourself into unnecessary problems.

Squeakers

These tend to make the toy more fun and entertaining to play with, so it would be wise if you go for squeaky toys.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

The following questions aim to boost your understanding of the best plush dog toys so that you can end up with the best choice of them all.

Are toy stuffings dangerous for my dog?

In most cases, they pass out of the body with the stool. However, there is a likelihood of them clogging up the intestines, which may be risky, and expensive surgery would be needed to solve the problem.

Therefore, supervision would be necessary to ensure that your canine does not get to the inside of its plush toy.

Is the brand an essential factor to consider?

Yes, it is. This is because the brands which have been in the game for longer know their flaws and therefore have ample time to fix their issues.

They are also likely to have analyzed their customer preferences, so they would have a pattern of giving people what they want.

When is the best time to withdraw the plush toy?

In this case, you should observe how your pooch plays with the toy. When you notice that it has become too aggressive in its chewing and handling of the toy, it would be wise that you withdraw it and get it an appropriate chewing toy.

The Best Overall

At the end of our analysis, we have settled on the Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Plush Puzzle Toy as the best of them all. Not only does it keep your pet busy, but it also stimulates its brain, which is crucial in boosting his intelligence.

It is also a versatile toy that offers your pet more than one way of playing with it.

Wrapping It Up

Next time you want to get your pooch the best plush dog toys, do not hesitate to go back to our simple guide plus the recommended brands, which we believe are the best in the market.

If you follow the recommendations and considerations that we have given, then nothing should stop you from getting the best plush dog toy which would keep your pooch occupied.

Leave a Comment