The Best Catnip Toys in 2019 - Reviews & Buyer’s Guide

As a cat owner, you’re probably always thinking of how to make your feline friend happy and comfortable. If this is the case, then you should consider buying your kitty the best catnip toys. The toys will not only turn your kittens into playful cats but will also make them extra lovey-dovey.

Unfortunately, not all catnip toys are made equal. In fact, some catnip toys may not have any impact on your cat while others might have a more sedative effect.

The good news is that there are a million types of catnip toys available to choose from. And we are here to help you narrow down the choices.

Some quick highlights of what we are going to cover in this review include:

  • Some of the key factors to look out for when buying one
  • Frequently asked questions
  • Which is the best choice and why

Top-Rated 12 Best Catnip Toys for Cat 2019 - Comparison Table

To bring you some of the best products, we sourced only for highly-reviewed catnip toys that suit any cats’ personality. We hope this will help you make an informed decision and get your cat ready for some addictive fun. 

Picture
EDITOR'S CHOICE
HARTZ Just For Cats Kitty Frenzy Catnip Mice Toys...
KONG - Kickeroo Cozie - Play Enticing Cat Toy,...
(Refillable Pocket) 15" Catnip Cat Kicker...
Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Cat Toy Catnip Mice,...
KONG Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy (Colors Vary)
Product Name
HARTZ Just For Cats Kitty Frenzy Catnip Mice Toys...
KONG - Kickeroo Cozie - Play Enticing Cat Toy,...
(Refillable Pocket) 15" Catnip Cat Kicker...
Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Cat Toy Catnip Mice,...
KONG Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy (Colors Vary)
Color
Hunt
vary
Green
yellow
-
Vary
Weight
1.1 ounces
0.3 ounces
4 ounces
4 ounces
0.8 ounces
1.6 ounces
Prime Status
-
-
EDITOR'S CHOICE
Picture
HARTZ Just For Cats Kitty Frenzy Catnip Mice Toys...
Product Name
HARTZ Just For Cats Kitty Frenzy Catnip Mice Toys...
Color
Hunt
Weight
1.1 ounces
Prime Status
Check Latest Price
Picture
KONG - Kickeroo Cozie - Play Enticing Cat Toy,...
Product Name
KONG - Kickeroo Cozie - Play Enticing Cat Toy,...
Color
vary
Weight
0.3 ounces
Prime Status
-
Check Latest Price
Picture
(Refillable Pocket) 15" Catnip Cat Kicker...
Product Name
(Refillable Pocket) 15" Catnip Cat Kicker...
Color
Green
Weight
4 ounces
Prime Status
-
Check Latest Price
Picture
Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana
Product Name
Yeowww! Catnip Toy, Yellow Banana
Color
yellow
Weight
4 ounces
Prime Status
Check Latest Price
Picture
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Cat Toy Catnip Mice,...
Product Name
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Cat Toy Catnip Mice,...
Color
-
Weight
0.8 ounces
Prime Status
Check Latest Price
Picture
KONG Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy (Colors Vary)
Product Name
KONG Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy (Colors Vary)
Color
Vary
Weight
1.6 ounces
Prime Status
Check Latest Price

The Best Catnip Toys in 2019

1. Hartz Just For Cats Toy

It is wise that you ensure your cat is always busy and running around. In this way, they can exercise their instincts so that whenever they end up in their natural environment, they would have an easy time adapting and catching their prey.

A catnip toy would come in handy for this purpose, and at this point, we shall introduce you to this set from Hartz.

Product Description

This set comes in a pack of thirteen toys, including three catnip toys featuring a fish and two mice. Additionally, the kit includes six balls, one wand baton and three poms. These toys are of the ideal size to resemble the prey, so this should ensure the cat is always motivated to play around with them.

The toys lightweight and so the cat should have an easy time carrying them as well as tossing them around.

Other Features and Benefits

All the toys in the package are brightly colored, and this should be of help while you clean up after the cat is done playing for the day. You should easily spot them, whether it is under the furniture or in the flower bed as they stand out.

They also have a compact design, and this means they do not break apart easily and as a result, become easy to toss and play around with.

Pros

  • Lightweight and compact
  • Well-priced
  • Compact and brightly colored

Cons

  • They have incredibly sharp edges which may hurt the cat

2. KONG Cozie Kickeroo Catnip Cat Toy

If you want your cat to have a toy that can double up as a toy as well as a comfort item that it can cuddle up in when the playtime is over, the Cat Cozie Kickeroo Toy would be a good place to start. This quality makes the toy well-suited for the younger or rescued cats which tend to have a feeling of insecurity in them.

Our review should give you a deeper understanding of why we believe this toy is one that is worth having in your household.

Product Description

This toy is manufactured in the USA, and it is made out of soft and plush fabric, and this makes it double up as a play toy as well as a comfort item. It may be smaller than other toys in the Kong brand, but your cat should still have a great time in tackling and cuddling up with the toy.

As the cat plays with the toy, it produces a crinkly sound which encourages the pet to keep on playing with it. There is also the fluffy tail that once in motion, brings up excitement and motivates the cat to keep on exercising.

It is available in three versions, a green frog, a purple raccoon and a brown bear, so you get to choose your preferred version.

Other Features and Benefits

One advantage with this toy is that it does not require your supervision as the cat plays with it. This is because it does not have small removable parts that may choke the cat, nor does it have any parts where the cat may get stuck in.

It is cozy and encourages your cat to wrestle more. As a result, your cat should exercise more with this toy.

Pros

  • Dual-purpose item
  • Durable construction
  • No supervision required

Cons

  • You cannot open it up to refill Catnip

3. West Coast Pet Products 15” Catnip Cat Kicker Toy

Does your cat enjoy doing hind paw kicking? If it does, West Coast Pet Products has the perfect toy for your pet in the form of the 15-Inch Catnip kicker toy. It features a side pocket through which you can add Catnip, and this should help you avoid buying a new one whenever the scent wears off.

Product Description

This toy is handmade in the USA, and it is constructed out of heavyweight cotton fabric. Additionally, all the seams are double sewn, and this coupled with the heavy-duty material, should give the toy sturdiness and longevity.

It is filled with 1.25 ounces of fresh Canadian Catnip and has a side pocket that you shall use in refilling the Catnip whenever its scent wears off.

Other Features and Benefits 

With this toy, you can be sure that you are receiving a very fresh item as they are made to be shipped on the same day they are made. Further, the side pocket should come in handy as you can always refill the worn-out Catnip instead of purchasing a new toy.

Still, on the side pocket, it is sturdy enough to ensure that no catnip falls out as the cat plays with the toy.

Then, at 15-inches long and 2.5-inches wide, this toy is quite large and has an ideal size to encourage your cat to wrestle with it for extended periods.

Pros

  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Refillable
  • Well-sized

Cons

  • Refilling can be hard

4. Yeowww Banana Catnip Cat Toy

If you are looking for a Catnip toy for your cat that is completely non-toxic, the Yeowww brand has an item for you. It is filled with 100% organic catnip so that in case your cat gets through the fabric; nothing should worry you as your pet shall remain safe all through.

Other than that, our review will focus on other features so that you can understand why this particular toy is so highly-rated.

Product Description

This toy is handmade in the USA, and it is constructed out of heavy-duty cotton material which is dyed with natural vegetable or soy components. Apart from the banana version, this catnip toy is also available in the form of a lemon, apple and a rainbow.

It features a zipper closure and has no cotton or polyester fillings.

Other features and Benefits

First, the cotton material is very tough and should withstand the sharp claws and teeth of the cat. This implies that it is durable and should serve you for a long time to come.

Then, the banana curve is a convenient shape for the cat to carry around and toss it around playfully.

Although it is not dish-washable, it is easy to spot-clean it to ensure it remains in a decent condition.

Pros

  • Sturdy and durable construction
  • 100% organic catnip
  • Affordable

Cons

  • Not for larger cats

5. SmartyKat Catnip Cat Toys

If you are sensitive to environmental conservation, this Catnip toy from SmartyKat is just for you. It has a chemical-free composition and comprises of fiberfill which is made of recycled plastic. As a result, it should be perfectly safe for you, your cat and the environment as well.

Product Description

This package contains three mice which are filled with pure and potent Catnip that is free from any toxic composition. The cat should find this substance to be enticing, and this intends to motivate the pet to play with the toy more.

The toys measure 4-Inches long, and this is the ideal size for the cat to carry and play around with comfortably. They are also constructed from eco-friendly materials which are recyclable, renewable and certified as organic. This makes them safe for the cat and the surroundings as well.

Other Features and Benefits

The Catnip serves to attract the cat to the toys, and this should ensure that your cat remains active for longer durations. As a result, the pet should have exercised more and shall hone their predatory instincts even better.

The mice catnip toys are lightweight, and this makes them easy for your cat to carry around.

Pros

  • Well-sized
  • Eco-friendly and non-toxic to the cat
  • Easy to carry around

Cons

  • Tears apart easily

6. Kong Beaver Refillable Catnip Toy

Kong does it again with this beaver Catnip Toy which is soft plush, and your cat should enjoy the experience of playing around with this toy. It is different from most of the other Catnip Toys in that it does not arrive filled with Catnip but comes with a bottle beside which contains this substance.

Product Description

Made in the USA, this is a soft plush toy with a special compartment where you will be placing the Catnip. The Catnip is included in a small plastic bottle, and you can always refill the toy whenever the need arises.

The Catnip is 100% natural and is made from a herb that motivates the cat to play more and as a result, should exercise more as well.

Lastly, you can always freeze the extra Catnip so that you can use it whenever the need arises.

Other Features and Benefits

The special compartment is easy to open and close, and this should give you an easy time as you refill the toy with Catnip. This compartment also ensures that the cat does not get to the Catnip that easily as it would when the substance was closer to the surface.

Then, the standby Catnip should come in handy when the present one fades away as they have a reputation of not being that durable.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Features a special compartment for the Catnip
  • Refillable

Cons

  • Not very durable

7. SmartyKat Value Pack Cat Toys

SmartyKat is a significant player in the Catnip cat toy industry, and this pack may be one of the best that you shall come across. It features ten mice that are filled with pure and potent Catnip which serve to keep your cat busy for extended periods.

Product Description

This pack comprises of ten mice, and this makes it well-suited for a household with several cats. The mice are perfectly sized at four inches long for the cat to carry and toss around in the house.

The Catnip is pure and potent and 100% free from any toxic chemical components. The materials are certified organic, and even if your cat gets through the fabric, it will not pose any risk to the pet.

Other Features and Benefits

The first advantage with this set of toys comes in the coloring. An excessively colored toy would put off the smarter cats so this particular set features moderately colored mice with little dots to act as eyes. In this case, they resemble real mice even more.

Then, they are eco-friendly as well and so will not pose a hazardous risk to the surroundings.

Pros

  • Has an appropriate size for carrying and batting
  • Non-toxic and ecofriendly Catnip
  • The mice have a more realistic design

Cons

  • The tails tend to come off too easily

8. SmartyKat Fish Friends Crinkle and Catnip Cat Toys

If you are looking for the complete package in catnip cat toys, this set from SmartyKat is here for you. From affordability to design and eco-friendliness, the manufacturer of this particular set focused on all the core aspects of a Catnip cat toy that should make you go for it.

The idea was that the set should fulfill all your pet’s needs and encourage him to remain active.

Product Description

This toy set is manufactured in the USA, and all the toys are uniquely designed. They include crinkle material, natural feathers and sting, all of which should bring out the cat's instincts. 

The package includes three toys, all of which are textured, have a crinkle sound and are brightly colored so that the cat should have an easy time in locating them. They are filled with natural Catnip that is free from chemicals or pesticides and therefore non-toxic.

They are constructed out of recycled plastic, and this contributes to their eco-friendliness.

Other Features and Benefits

If you are concerned about your cat coming into contact with toxic substances, this set should relax your mind as they are filled with pure and potent Catnip that is 100% safe for the pet.

Another benefit is that the Catnip is genuine, unlike some other toys with artificial fillers.

The Catnip is likely to bring out a burst of energy, and then a mellow period should set in, and this is crucial to the overall growth of the cat.

Lastly, they are affordable, and so if they get lost or destroyed, you should have an easy time finding the perfect replacements.

Pros

  • Eco-friendly
  • Non-toxic composition
  • Well-priced

Cons

  • Not durable

9. Kong Rat Refillable Catnip Toy

As you probably know, the rat is the cat's main prey within your household and so having a Rat Catnip Cat Toy should bring out its instincts to the maximum. The Kong brand must have had this thought in mind when they came up with the Rat Refillable Catnip Toy.

It is a plush toy that your cat should enjoy playing around with.

Product Description

This toy is manufactured in the USA, and it contains natural North American Catnip which should stimulate your cat into getting into a playful mode, as is its role. It features a special compartment where you will be placing the Catnip.

In case you have extra Catnip, you can always freeze it so that it remains fresh and produce the intended effect from the cat. Further, it is refillable, so once the catnip scent wears off, you do not have to get a new toy, and this makes it cost-effective.

It is a plush soft toy, and your cat should enjoy playing around with it for extended periods.

Other Features and Benefits

One benefit of this particular toy is that you can enhance how your kitty's enjoyment by gently squeezing the toy to release the Catnip's oil. This should motivate the cat to play and exercise more.

The Catnip is non-toxic and should not have any negative impact on the cat. Then, it is washable to keep it in good condition.

Pros

  • Fluffy and soft
  • Refillable
  • Made in the USA

Cons

  • The fabric is too thin

10. Molly’s Mice Catnip Cat Toy

If you are a fan of handmade Catnip cat toys, this product by Molly's Mice is one that is worth trying. It is filled with maximum strength leaf and flower catnip with no material filling whatsoever. Although it is not refillable, it is very affordable, and you can always purchase a couple of them at once for a quick replacement once one of them wears out.

Product Description

This toy is made in England, and it is available in seven different colors, so you get to choose the one that you feel would be the most appealing to your cat. The outer and the mouse tail are both made of 100% cotton, to make it soft and durable.

It measures 12cm long and 5cm deep and has undergone various tests to ensure that you are landing a high-quality product that should serve you well for a long time to come.

Other Features and Benefits

The first benefit is that unlike other catnip toys, this particular one has some use once the cat is done with it. Instead of disposing of it, you can always place it on your shelf to serve as some form of decoration.

All the manufacturing from the cutting to the stitching and filling is done by hand to minimize the margin of error associated with machinery.

Pros

  • No material fillings
  • Soft and durable cotton construction
  • Has a decorative aspect

Cons

  • Not refillable

11. JZMYXA Wand Catnip Cat Toy

If you are looking for a Catnip Cat Toy that would make the perfect gift for your friend who owns a cat, this item from the JZMYXA brand is here for you. It comes in the form of a cat wand and a catnip feather pillow which would always be enticing to the cat to keep on playing around.

We have a more in-depth review on this cat wand to give you a better understanding of it.

Product Description

This toy is made in the USA, and the package includes a cat wand, a cat bell, a catnip feather pillow and an elastic band. The wand is constructed out of high-quality carbon fiber, which is sturdy and capable of withstanding rough handling by the cat. It can hold accommodate a weight of up to 4lbs without breaking apart.

It features a soft and durable EVA handle which has three sections of adjustable lengths, including 14.6-Inches, 25.8-Inches and 38.5-Inches.

The high-quality turkey feathers serve to stimulate the cat’s predatory instincts while the lacquer cat bell should capture the kitty’s attention and keep him active all day long.

Other Features and Benefits

The wand's EVA handle is comfortable and attractive, plus is anti-slip, and so it will not slide out of your hands easily.

Then, the entire toy is lightweight, and so your hand will not get fatigued easily as you play around with your cat.

Another advantage is that the Catnip is tasty and 100% natural so it should be safe for your cat.

Pros

  • Sturdy construction
  • The wand has an adjustable length
  • Lightweight

Cons

  • Expensive

12. Kong Kickeroo Giraffe Pattern Wrestling Catnip Toy

A wrestling cat toy serves to sharpen the pet's paw-kicking and its snuggling ability. As a result, the cat should have a better mastery of hunting and tackling its prey. An excellent example of an appropriate wrestling cat toy is this model from the Kong brand which intends to bring out your cat's predatory instincts.

Is it worth it? Check out our review below and see.

Product Description

This toy has a long plush body, and it should encourage your cat to wrestle and snuggle more with it. Additionally, it intends to promote your pet's hind paw kicking. It has a giraffe pattern which should capture your cat's attention to encourage it to play more with it.

Still, on attention, the fluffy tail intends to bring out the kitty's desire to hunt and capture its prey. It also produces a clinking sound when you swing it around, and so the cat should enjoy playing with it.

It features the potent North American Catnip, and this has the purpose of ensuring your cat remains entertained and busy for extended periods.

Other Features and Benefits

Apart from the giraffe pattern, this toy is also available in a tiger as well as the pink cow pattern. This gives you the option to choose the appearance that you feel should blend better with your interior house décor.

If your cat is a big fan of larger toys, this Kong Kickeroo model would be the perfect gift, and this should increase the bond between you two.

Pros

  • Attractive appearance
  • Contains potent North American Catnip
  • Durable

Cons

  • Tail fibers fall off easily

Factors to Consider When Buying Catnip Toys

There is no doubt that catnip toys come with many benefits. Besides helping to keep your kittens physically active and entertained, they also keep them happy and healthy.  But with so many different catnip toys available on the market, it’s hard not to feel overwhelmed with the choices.

Luckily, you really don’t need to make the purchasing decisions on your own. In this buying guide, we provide you with plenty of advice on how to pick the right one for your kitty.

That said, consider the following things before making any purchasing decision. 

Dried Catnip vs Sprays vs Fresh Catnip

Dried catnip is the most common on the market. Simply put, it is catnip that is gathered and then the leaves are dried and later cut up into fine pieces. This type of catnip is preferred by most cat owners as it is cheaper, lasts longer and is easier to store.

Most kitties are not as interested in catnip sprays as they are in fresh or dried catnip. This type of catnip is best used when you don’t want your feline friend to scratch your furniture. All you need is to spritz a little bit of it onto the particular place you would prefer them to scratch.

When it comes to fresh catnip, you can choose to grow your own or simply buy it from a pet supply store or a greenhouse. The advantage that this type of catnip has over the rest is that it’s highly effective and free of any preservatives.

Preservatives and Artificial Fillers

Some manufacturers tend to use artificial fillers or even preservatives to keep their products more potent or fresher. Therefore, always be on the lookout for brands that might contain ethoxyquin, BHA, and/or BHT. And if you want the best catnip toy for your kitty, look for an all-natural and organic product.

Amount of Leaves

If you want a highly-effective catnip toy, the more leaves, the better. Unfortunately, a few manufacturers tend to mix almost everything into the catnip mix including the roots, seed, branches, and stems. This is usually indicated on the ingredients list.

Although it is generally harmless, catnip toys with fewer leaves can be much less attractive to your kitties. Not to mention, the roots, branches, and stems could hurt your cat’s mouth in the event they decide to eat it.

Potency

While buying catnip toys, you want first to be sure that it’s going to affect your kitty in the desired way. As such, the best catnip should be potent enough and aromatic. Basically, the more potent the catnip is, the longer it will last. Also, the aromatic properties of the catnip should be very strong to make your cat enjoy it.

Versatility

Generally, the best catnip toy should be made in such a way to ensure your kitty gets the complete experience out of it. As such, versatility is yet another factor to consider. Simply put, the catnip toy must be incredibly flexible to play with, snuggly and fluffy enough. This is just in case your kitty would like to sleep with it close by. It should also be big enough to allow for realistic play.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Catnip harmful to cats?

​No, it’s not. However, it is possible for a cat to “overdose” in a way. In addition, ingesting too much of it can result to upset stomach and vomiting. Therefore, it’s advisable to keep the kitty’s playtime with the toy for preset periods to avoid problems.

Will my cat react to catnip?

It is estimated that only 70% to 80% of cats react with catnip. Usually, the reaction is hereditary. As such, there are entire breeds of cats that never pay attention to it. Therefore, if you have several cats of the different or same breed, you should introduce the catnip individually to each of them.

Why is it that cats love catnip toys so much?

​Catnip contains a chemical known as nepetalactone that triggers a response in the brains of susceptible cats. This makes them get excited enough to go out and play.

Can I give my kitty the catnip toy too often?

​Yes but if you give your cat the catnip all the time, it might start becoming a lot less effective for them. It can also cause addiction which is not really a problem but you probably don’t want it to become less effective.

Which One is the Best?

Overall, the Hartz Just for Cats Toy is our best choice. It combines two things that cats love most including catnip and mice. Also, the toy is packed with premium catnip which makes it a no match for even the cleverest kitties.

Final Words

Keep your lovely kittens happy, entertained and active with one of this fun, stimulating catnip toys. Whatever your budget is, you will find the best catnip toys to delight your cat for hours and hours.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: